The sources
What owners report paying: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey
Table B25141, “Homeowners Insurance Costs by Mortgage Status (Yearly),” counts owner-occupied homes by what the owner says they pay a year for fire, hazard and flood insurance on the property. We use the 5-year survey (2020–2024) for every county, ZIP (ZCTA) and census tract, and the 1-year survey (2025) for states.
- Typical cost is the median, interpolated within the Census cost brackets ($100–$299, $300–$499, … $3,500–$3,999, $4,000 or more).
- We count owners who pay $100 or more. The survey also counts owners who report paying under $100, mostly condo owners whose building carries the policy, plus homes with no insurance. That's about 1 in 7 owners nationally and nearly 1 in 3 in Miami Beach. Including them would drag typical costs down and flatter everyone's rank.
- It includes flood and wind policies the owner carries, because owners report the total.
- The 5-year survey is in 2024 dollars. Recent increases show up more in the 1-year state figures.
- Every estimate has a margin of error. These are survey estimates, not counts. In a small county or ZIP only a few dozen owners may answer, so we publish ranges below the state level and hide any figure that fails the checks under When we don't show a number. Where we show your rank, we say how many owners the estimate represents.
Bringing survey figures up to 2025 prices
Your rank compares what you pay today with what owners reported in the 2020–2024 survey, when premiums were lower. Ranking a 2026 bill against 2020–2024 prices would put almost everyone above the middle. So before we rank you, we bring the survey up to 2025 prices:
- The adjustment is your state's own change. We divide the state's median from the 2025 1-year survey by its median from the 2020–2024 survey. In Texas that's about 1.32, a 32% rise.
- We scale the whole distribution by it. Every cost bracket for your ZIP, county or state is multiplied by that factor, and your premium is ranked against the result. The typical cost and the “$4,000 or more” line on your report are in the same 2025 prices, and labeled that way.
- It's kept within limits. The factor is never below 1.0 (prices never adjusted down) and never above 1.6. If either state figure is missing or top-coded, we don't adjust.
- It's an approximation. It assumes prices in your area rose as fast as in your state as a whole. Coastal and hail-belt areas may have risen faster.
The map and area pages show each survey's own figures, labeled with the survey's years, without this adjustment.
Flood insurance: FEMA, federal flood insurance (NFIP)
FEMA publishes every National Flood Insurance Program policy (OpenFEMA “FIMA NFIP Redacted Policies v3,” about 75 million records). We keep the policies in force on the dataset's latest date and group them by state, county, tract and ZIP.
- Typical flood policy is the median yearly cost of single-unit policies. A condo building's master policy covers many units, so it would pose as one household's very large bill; it counts toward policies but not prices.
- Homes with flood insurance (take-up) is insured units divided by housing units (Census B25001).
- FEMA's full price for the risk. Since FEMA's Risk Rating 2.0, many policies are still climbing toward what FEMA says the risk is worth. By law, increases are capped at 18% a year for primary homes, and at 25% a year for many second homes, rentals and businesses. We show how far prices still have to rise.
- Comparing your flood policy. Where we know your building coverage, your report compares cost per $1,000 of building coverage, so a bigger policy isn't mistaken for a pricier one.
- Our state totals are checked against FEMA's own monthly policies-in-force report.
This product uses the Federal Emergency Management Agency's OpenFEMA API, but is not endorsed by FEMA.
Official averages: state insurance regulators
Where a state publishes average premiums, we show them as the official average: Texas (Department of Insurance, average premiums by county; its ZIP-level data is policy counts and nonrenewals, with no prices), Florida (Office of Insurance Regulation), California (Department of Insurance), Alabama, Massachusetts and Missouri. Each is labeled with the regulator's name and year. About 30 states publish nothing useful about what homeowners pay.
U.S. Treasury and Congress
The Treasury's Federal Insurance Office published ZIP-level homeowners premiums, claims and nonrenewals for 2018–2022 (HO-3 and HO-5 policies). The Senate Budget Committee published nonrenewal rates by state and county for 2018–2023. We use them for trends and context, always with their years, because they're older.
Neighbors
People share what they pay. A typed-in rate counts as shared. A rate read from an uploaded policy declarations page (the summary page of your policy) and checked counts as verified, and only verified rates build neighbor comparisons. A neighbor figure appears only once at least 10 verified rates exist in that area. How we verify a rate.
Why the official average and the Census figure differ
In Harris County, Texas, owners in the 2020–2024 survey report a typical $2,200–$2,500 a year, while the Texas Department of Insurance's 2025 average policy with wind coverage is above $4,000. Both are right; they measure different things:
- On the coast, wind is split out. In Texas's coastal counties, TDI reports policies with wind coverage separately from those without. Most coastal homes buy wind separately from the Texas Windstorm Insurance Association (TWIA), so the “with wind” average describes a minority of homes. Where you tell us your policy leaves wind out, we compare you with TDI's average for policies without wind.
- The regulator's figure is an average across every policy, pulled up by large and expensive homes. The Census figure is a median, the middle owner.
- The regulator counts what insurers charged this year. The Census 5-year survey spans 2020–2024, in 2024 dollars, a period when premiums rose fast.
- The Census asks owners. Some round, some guess, and some report only part of what they pay.
We show both, labeled, and never blend them.
Why our national and Florida figures are lower than the ones in the news
Our national typical cost, and Florida's, sit well below the figures most news stories quote. That's not an error. The usual press figure is an average premium per policy, often for standard homeowners policies on houses, sometimes a quote for one sample house. Ours is the median of what owners report paying, counting every owner who pays $100 or more, condo owners included. Condo policies cover only the inside of the unit and cost much less, and a median isn't pulled up by the most expensive homes. In Florida, the regulator's average policy with wind coverage was $3,738 (March 31, 2026); the 2025 Census median is $2,687. Read more in why the state average and the Census figure differ.
What's public, and what you unlock
- Exact figures are public at state level. See costs by state.
- Counties and ZIPs show ranges on the map, in seven bands per layer (home: under $1,000 up to $2,800 or more).
- Share what you pay and you see the exact figures for your area, and exactly where you rank. The Census and FEMA tables themselves are public and linked above. What you unlock is our cleaning, the exact figures from bands, the 2025 price adjustment, the regulator comparison, and figures from neighbors that exist only because people shared them.
When we don't show a number
- Census figures need at least 30 paying owners in the estimate and a margin of error no more than half the estimate.
- Flood figures need at least 10 policies.
- Neighbor comparisons need at least 10 verified rates.
- Data a source hasn't confirmed is meant to be public stays unpublished.
Updates
Flood data refreshes monthly, Census figures each fall when new surveys are released, and regulator figures when each state publishes. Blog posts are pinned to the data run they used, so their numbers never change silently.
- November 14, 2026: home figures now count owners who pay $100 or more (see above).
- November 14, 2026: this page now explains the 2025 price adjustment used for ranks, the flood caps for second homes, and why our figures run below those in the news.
Citing our figures
You may reference and quote our state- and ZIP-level figures with attribution: “What My Neighbors Pay” with the page URL, plus the underlying source and year shown with each figure. Reproducing the dataset in whole or in substantial part needs our written consent; see Using our data. Sister sites: Home Insurance Index and Auto Insurance Index.