Explainer

Home

Why your state's 'average' home insurance and the Census figure disagree (and which to trust)

Texas says its average homeowners policy cost $3,489 in 2025. Texas owners told the Census the typical bill was $2,599. Both are right. Here's why official averages and Census figures differ, with six states as examples.

What My Neighbors Pay 6 min read

Look up what home insurance costs in your state and you'll often find two numbers that don't match. One is the state regulator's average premium. The other is what owners told the Census Bureau they pay.

The short answer: they measure different things. The regulator's figure is usually an average across every policy insurers sold. The Census figure is the median owner, the one in the middle. They also cover different years, different policies and different coverage. Neither is wrong. Each answers a different question.

$890

is the gap between Texas's official 2025 average homeowners premium ($3,489) and the typical cost Texas owners reported to the Census ($2,599)Texas Department of Insurance, 2025 (preliminary); U.S. Census Bureau, ACS 2025 1-year, table B25141

What's the difference between an average and a median?

Picture five neighbors. They pay $1,500, $1,800, $2,000, $2,400 and $9,000 a year.

  • The median is the middle bill: $2,000.
  • The average adds them up and divides by five: $3,340.

One big bill moves the average a lot and the median not at all. Home insurance has plenty of big bills: large houses, coastal homes, older roofs. So in most places the average sits above the median.

State regulators usually publish an average, because it's what their data gives: total premium divided by the number of policies. The Census survey sorts answers into price ranges, so the natural figure is the median.1

Why are the numbers from different years?

The Census figure we use for states is from the 2025 survey. Regulators publish on their own schedules, often a year or more behind. Some are much older. In a market where prices have risen fast, a few years makes a big difference.

Do both numbers count the same policies?

Often not. Some regulator averages blend in renters, condo and landlord policies. Renters policies cost a small fraction of a homeowners policy, so they pull an average down.

The Census asks only owners who live in the home. We count owners who report paying $100 a year or more. That leaves out about 1 in 7 owners nationally, mostly condo owners whose building's policy covers them, plus homes with no insurance.1

What's included: wind and flood?

The Census asks what the owner pays for fire, hazard and flood insurance, so a separate flood or wind policy is in the owner's total. A regulator's homeowners average usually counts only the homeowners policy. A separate flood policy, or a separate wind policy on the coast, isn't in it.

How do the two numbers compare in Texas, Florida and other states?

Here's how the two numbers line up where a state publishes an official average.

State Official average Year and what it covers Census typical, 2025
Texas $3,489 2025, homeowners policies $2,599
Florida $3,738 March 2026, homeowners with wind $2,687
California $1,674 2023, homeowners policies $1,811
Missouri $1,872 2023, homeowners policies $1,903
Massachusetts $1,699 2020, homeowners policies $1,976
Alabama $1,642 2024, all residential policies $1,814

Sources: state regulators as noted below; U.S. Census Bureau, ACS 2025 1-year, table B25141, owners paying $100 or more.

There's a pattern. Where the official average is current, it's higher than the Census median. Where it's older or blended, it's lower.

Texas: a current average, well above the median

The Texas Department of Insurance's 2025 statewide average for homeowners policies was $3,489, still marked preliminary.2 Texas owners reported a typical $2,599. The official average is 34% higher.

This is mostly average versus median. In Texas, 24.4% of paying owners reported $4,000 or more, and the survey can't tell $4,100 from $12,000. Those big bills lift an average and leave the middle alone. TDI's average coverage was $432,800 in 2025, and big policies carry big premiums.

Wind works the other way here. On the coast, about 213,000 homeowners policies leave wind out, averaging $1,328, and those owners buy wind coverage separately from the Texas Windstorm Insurance Association, at an average $2,633.2 An owner reporting to the Census would likely count both bills. So the Census figure includes more coverage, and it's still lower.

Florida: the same pattern, plus condos

Florida's Office of Insurance Regulation data put the average homeowners policy with wind coverage at $3,738 as of March 31, 2026.3 Florida owners reported a typical $2,687.

The year isn't the cause. On September 30, 2025, the same average was $3,772. The bigger reasons are average versus median, and who's counted. The regulator puts condo unit-owner policies in their own group, averaging $1,792 with wind. The Census median includes condo owners who pay for a unit policy. And 20.9% of Florida owners, about 1 in 5, reported paying under $100, so they're left out of the Census figure entirely.

California: older data, and a blend you should skip

California's Department of Insurance reports a 2023 average of $1,674 for homeowners policies.4 Californians reported a typical $1,811 in 2025.

Here the Census figure is higher. Two years of rising prices is the likely reason. The department's homeowners average rose from $1,050 in 2018 to $1,674 in 2023, up 59%.

California also shows the blend problem clearly. Across all residential policy types, the department's 2023 average was $1,130. That includes renters policies, averaging $171, and condo policies, at $719. Only about half of the policies in that blend were homeowners policies. Quote $1,130 as "what Californians pay for home insurance" and you'd be off by a lot.

Missouri: two years apart

Missouri's Department of Commerce and Insurance put the 2023 average homeowners premium at $1,872.5 Missourians reported a typical $1,903 in 2025.

These look like a match, but they aren't measuring the same moment. The department's average rose from $1,661 in 2022 to $1,872 in 2023, up 13% in one year. If prices kept rising after 2023, a current average would likely sit above the Census median, as it does in Texas and Florida.

Massachusetts: an official average from 2020

The newest official average we have for Massachusetts is from 2020: $1,699 for homeowners policies, from the Division of Insurance's statistical supplement.6 Massachusetts owners reported a typical $1,976 in 2025. Five years separate the two, and the Census's own figures show prices rising over that time: owners reported a typical $1,566 across the 2020–2024 survey (in 2024 dollars).

The same 2020 report shows how much policy type matters. Condo policies averaged $480 and renters policies $188.

Alabama: everything in one number

Alabama's Department of Insurance reports a 2024 average of $1,642.7 It covers all residential policies: homeowners, condo, dwelling fire, renters and mobile home combined. Alabamians reported a typical $1,814 in 2025.

A blend like this counts more policies than there are owner-occupied homes: about 1,685,000 policies in 2024, against 1,468,988 owner households in the 2025 survey. The cheaper policy types pull the average down. Prices were rising fast, too. The same average was $1,261 in 2022, so it rose 30% in two years.

So which number should you trust?

Both, as long as each one is labeled.

  • The regulator's average is the best measure of what insurers actually charged, from their own books. Check the year and which policies it covers.
  • The Census median is closer to what a typical owner pays, and it covers every state the same way. It's self-reported, includes flood, and comes in price ranges.

What you shouldn't do is blend them, or compare one state's average to another state's median. We show both side by side, each with its source and year, and never mix them.1

What's the best way to compare your own bill?

Neither number tells you whether your price is normal. A $2,600 bill can be a good deal on one house and a poor one on the house next door. It depends on the coverage amount, the deductible, the roof and the company.

The fairest comparison is like for like: homes near you with similar coverage and the same deductible. That takes real policy details, which is why a policy declarations page (the summary page of your policy) matters more than a typed-in number. It shows exactly what the price buys.

Check your home insurance: share what you pay, or upload your declarations page, and see where you stand among homes near you. How every figure on the site is built is on our methodology page.

Sources

  1. U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2025 1-year estimates, table B25141, Homeowners Insurance Costs by Mortgage Status (Yearly). Summary File: https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/acs/summary_file/2025/table-based-SF/data/1YRData/acsdt1y2025-b25141.dat. Typical cost is the median among owners who report paying $100 or more, estimated from the survey's price ranges. Nationally, 12,815,914 of 87,511,734 owner households (14.6%) reported under $100. Owner-reported; includes flood insurance. See our methodology. ↩

  2. Texas Department of Insurance, Texas Homeowners Insurance Market Overview: statewide average premium for homeowners policies, 2025 (preliminary); average coverage; county map of policies with and without wind coverage and TWIA policies, in force December 31, 2025 (statewide policy-weighted averages are our calculation). https://www.tdi.texas.gov/general/texas-homeowners-insurance-market-overview.html ↩

  3. Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, Market Intelligence Report, statewide summary by company and policy type: https://floir.gov/tools-and-data/residential-market-share-reports. Our calculation: premium written divided by policies in force, owner-occupied homeowners policies with wind ($3,738 at March 31, 2026; $3,772 at September 30, 2025) and condo unit-owner policies with wind ($1,792 at March 31, 2026). Companies that claim trade secret are not included. OIR's Market Overview page shows $3,736 with wind (data as of October 2026): https://floir.gov/property-casualty/market-overview ↩

  4. California Department of Insurance, Residential Property Coverage Amounts, Wildfire Risk and Losses (data file, 2018–2023): https://www.insurance.ca.gov/01-consumers/200-wrr/WildfireRiskInfoRpt.cfm. Average premium is earned premium divided by earned exposure. 2023: homeowners $1,674 (6,237,542 exposure years), all policy types $1,130 (12,580,970), renters $171, condo $719. ↩

  5. Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance, 2023 Homeowners Insurance Report: https://insurance.mo.gov/media/27646. Statewide average annual premium, 2014–2023. ↩

  6. Massachusetts Division of Insurance, Statistical Supplement to the 2020 home insurance report, Exhibit 5C (voluntary market and FAIR Plan, owner, condo and tenant forms; earned premium per earned house-year): https://malegislature.gov/Reports/13308/(1A)%20Final%20Home%20Insurance%20Report%202020%20Stat%20Supp.pdf. Report index: https://www.mass.gov/info-details/the-commissioners-report-on-home-insurance ↩

  7. Alabama Department of Insurance, Property Insurance Clarity Act data (Ala. Code § 27-22-21), statewide report: earned premium divided by policies in force, all residential policy types combined. https://aldoi.gov/Consumers/ClarityActConsumers.aspx ↩

Data as of Census ACS 2025 1-year; TDI 2025 (preliminary); FL OIR March 31, 2026; CDI 2023; MO DCI 2023; MA DOI 2020; AL DOI 2024. Every number in this story comes from a fixed run of our data pipeline (acs_home 2026-11-14T22:26:00Z; tx_tdi 2026-11-14T17:49:03Z; fl_oir 2026-11-14T17:49:45Z; ca_cdi_home 2026-11-14T17:54:20Z; mo_dci 2026-11-14T17:25:55Z; ma_doi 2026-11-14T17:52:15Z; al_doi 2026-11-14T17:51:03Z), so it won't change under you. No savings promises, no company rankings.

Your home policy

What do you pay for home insurance?

Share your yearly premium and see exactly where you stand among homes near you. Three questions, about 20 seconds, no account needed.

Check your home policy

Free. We never sell your data.