Data story

Home

In 30 states, the state won't tell you what your neighbors pay for home insurance

We checked all 50 states and DC. Only six publish average home insurance prices below the state level. In 30, the state publishes nothing useful at all.

What My Neighbors Pay 4 min read

Ask a neighbor what they pay for home insurance and you'll probably get a shrug. Ask your state, and in most of the country you'll get the same answer.

We read the website of every state insurance regulator in the country, plus the one in DC. We were looking for one thing: does the state tell people what homeowners near them actually pay? Not a brochure about shopping around. A number.1

30

states publish nothing useful about home insurance prices. Not by county, and not even a statewide average.What My Neighbors Pay review of 51 state regulator websites, November 2026

What we found

We sorted every state into four groups.

  • Six states publish real numbers below the state level. Texas, Florida, Alabama, Massachusetts, Missouri and California put out average premiums by county, ZIP code or rating area, in a form you can actually use.
  • Ten publish something partial. Usually a sample-rate guide that prices a made-up house with several companies, or averages buried in a PDF.
  • Five publish a statewide average and nothing finer.
  • Thirty publish nothing useful. That's New York, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Georgia, Illinois, Ohio, Michigan, Arizona, Washington, Louisiana and 20 more.2

One of the thirty, South Carolina, has a price comparison tool on paper. When we opened it, it came up blank. We've counted it with the thirty until we can confirm otherwise.

That's more than half of America's homeowners

The Census Bureau counts about 87.5 million homeowner households in the U.S. About 46.2 million of them, or 53%, live in one of those 30 states.3

So for most homeowners, there is no official place to look up what the house down the street pays. Not the county average. Not the ZIP. Not even a ballpark from the people whose job is to watch the market.

46 million

homeowner households live in a state that publishes no useful home insurance price dataU.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2025 1-year, table B25141

Some states used to tell you

This wasn't always the case. Several states once published price guides and then stopped.

  • New Jersey printed a county-by-county premium comparison. The last one we could find is from 2009.4
  • Pennsylvania had a homeowners guide that compared rates by company in ten areas of the state. It ended somewhere between 2009 and 2011.
  • Delaware ran an online comparison tool until 2019, when the state repealed the rule behind it. The order called the tool obsolete.5
  • Louisiana passed a law in 2014 making insurers report premiums by ZIP code and parish. It expired on May 1, 2017, and the state stopped collecting the data.6

Louisiana is worth a second look. In 2025, 28.6% of homeowners there who pay for coverage told the Census they pay $4,000 a year or more for insurance. That's the second-highest share of any state, behind Florida.3 It's one of the most expensive places in the country to insure a home, and the state no longer gathers the numbers that would show where.

Some states collect it and keep it

In a few places the data exists. It just isn't published.

Illinois requires insurers to report home and auto data by ZIP code. What the public sees is a statewide report that splits the market into Chicago and everywhere else.7 Minnesota collects ZIP-level counts of policies, cancellations and nonrenewals. Missouri publishes county averages but holds raw ZIP data going back decades, available if you ask.

What it looks like when a state does publish

Texas shows what's possible. The Texas Department of Insurance publishes the average homeowners premium for every county, every year. Its 2025 statewide average, still preliminary, was $3,489.8 Anyone in Texas can see that Galveston County runs higher than El Paso County, and by how much.

That one table answers the question most people actually have: is what I pay normal for where I live?

Where the numbers do exist everywhere

There is one public source that covers every state. Each year the Census Bureau's American Community Survey asks homeowners what they pay for insurance on their home. It's the only national number that goes down to the ZIP code.

It has real limits. People report the cost themselves, so it can be a guess. It includes flood insurance in the same figure. And it comes in price ranges, not exact dollars.3 Still, it's the best public number most Americans have. In 2025 the typical U.S. homeowner reported paying about $1,706 a year. Like every Census cost figure on our site, that counts owners who report paying $100 or more. It runs below the averages often quoted in the news because it's a median, and condo owners are in it (why).

Why we built this

That gap is why What My Neighbors Pay exists. In 30 states, the only way to know what your neighbors pay is to ask them.

So we're asking. Share what you pay for home insurance, and we'll show you where you stand among homes near you. Upload your policy declarations page (the summary page of your policy) if you want, and your rate counts as verified. We read it, keep the numbers and delete the document within 24 hours, unless you ask us to keep it. In much of the country, rates people share will be the only current price data there is.

We'll keep checking state websites. If yours starts publishing, we'll say so here.

Sources

  1. What My Neighbors Pay review of all 50 state insurance regulators and DC, completed November 12, 2026. We graded each state A (averages below the state level in a usable form), B (sample-rate guides or sub-state averages in PDFs only), C (statewide averages only) or D (nothing useful). Our notes and links for every state are on file; we'll publish them with our methodology. ↩

  2. The 30 D-grade states: NJ, NY, PA, RI, VT, DE, VA, WV, SC, GA, TN, LA, AR, KS, NE, IA, MN, OH, IN, IL, MI, WI, ND, SD, MT, WY, NV, AZ, WA and AK. South Carolina's grade is still being confirmed. ↩

  3. U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2025 1-year estimates, table B25141 (homeowners insurance costs by mortgage status). Homeowner households (all owners): 87,511,734 nationally; 46,249,772 in the 30 D-grade states. Cost figures count owners who report paying $100 or more a year: Louisiana share paying $4,000 or more, 28.6%; U.S. median about $1,706. Owner-reported, includes flood insurance. ↩

  4. New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance, 2009 Homeowners Insurance Premium Comparison (for example, the Ocean County edition, dated August 2009): https://www.nj.gov/dobi/hoins_premiumcomparison/oceanco.pdf ↩

  5. Delaware Register of Regulations, May 2019, final order repealing Regulation 704: https://archive.regulations.delaware.gov/register/may2019/final/22%20DE%20Reg%20946%2005-01-19.htm ↩

  6. Louisiana Department of Insurance, Act 427 reporting: https://ldi.la.gov/industry/regulatory-forms/act-427 ↩

  7. Illinois Department of Insurance, 2026 Cost Containment Report: https://idoi.illinois.gov/content/dam/soi/en/web/insurance/reports/reports/2026-cc-report.pdf ↩

  8. Texas Department of Insurance, Texas Homeowners Insurance Market Overview (2025 figures preliminary): https://www.tdi.texas.gov/general/texas-homeowners-insurance-market-overview.html ↩

Data as of State regulator websites checked 2026-11-12; Census ACS 2025 1-year; TDI 2025 (preliminary). Every number in this story comes from a fixed run of our data pipeline (Research review 2026-11-12; acs_home 2026-11-14T22:26:00Z; tx_tdi 2026-11-14T17:49:03Z), so it won't change under you. No savings promises, no company rankings.

Your home policy

What do you pay for home insurance?

Share your yearly premium and see exactly where you stand among homes near you. Three questions, about 20 seconds, no account needed.

Check your home policy

Free. We never sell your data.