Data story

Home

Where homeowners report paying $4,000 or more for insurance

In 2025, 8.7 million American homeowners told the Census they pay $4,000 a year or more to insure their home. That's about 1 in 9 owners who pay for coverage, and in some places it's 1 in 2.

What My Neighbors Pay 4 min read

Four thousand dollars a year used to be a number you'd only hear on the Florida coast. Not anymore.

Every year the Census Bureau's American Community Survey asks homeowners what they pay for insurance on their home. The newest numbers, for 2025, show how far the $4,000 bill has spread.1

8.7 million

homeowner households reported paying $4,000 a year or more for home insurance in 2025U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2025 1-year, table B25141

About 1 in 9 homeowners

Out of 87.5 million homeowner households in the U.S., 74.7 million reported paying $100 a year or more for insurance. Of those, 8,706,227 said they pay $4,000 or more a year. That's 11.7%, or about 1 in 9.

Two years earlier it was far fewer. In 2023, the same survey counted about 5.4 million.2 That's roughly 3.3 million more households crossing the $4,000 line in two years.

The typical homeowner still pays much less. The middle answer nationally in 2025 was about $1,706 a year. But the top of the range is where the change is.

Homeowners with a mortgage were a bit more likely to be in that top group: 12.2%, compared with 10.8% of those who own their home outright.

Before we go further: what this number is

This is a good number with real limits, and they matter.

  • People report it themselves. It's what homeowners told a survey, not what an insurer billed. Some people guess, some round.
  • It includes flood insurance. The Census question covers fire, hazard and flood insurance together. On the coast, a flood policy can be a big part of the total.
  • It counts owners who pay $100 or more. Owners who report less, mostly condo owners whose building carries the policy plus homes with no insurance, are left out, as they are everywhere on this site (methodology).
  • It's homeowners only. No renters, no car insurance.
  • $4,000 is the top box. The survey sorts answers into ranges, and the highest one is "$4,000 or more." We can't tell $4,100 from $12,000. That's why we report the share in that box instead of an average.

With those caveats in mind, here's where it lands.

By state

Five states had at least 1 in 5 paying owners in the top box in 2025.

State Share paying $4,000 or more Households
Florida 29.6% 1,488,371
Louisiana 28.6% 286,738
Colorado 24.5% 355,652
Texas 24.4% 1,457,626
Nebraska 20.1% 93,473
Oklahoma 18.4% 157,639
Hawaii 15.8% 44,107
Minnesota 15.1% 228,952

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, ACS 2025 1-year, table B25141. Owners who report paying $100 or more a year.

Florida and Louisiana won't surprise anyone. Colorado might. Its share was 11.3% across 2020–2024 (a five-year blend, so not a perfect comparison), and more than double that in 2025. Nebraska, Oklahoma and Minnesota are on the list too, and none of them is on a hurricane coast.

At the other end, very few homeowners report bills that high in West Virginia (2.0%), Delaware (2.7%), Maine (3.1%), Vermont (3.3%) and Wisconsin (3.5%).

Texas and Florida together account for almost 3 million of the 8.7 million households.

By county

For counties, the newest Census figures blend five years of answers, 2020–2024. They're centered on about 2022, so they miss most of the 2025 jump you just saw in the states. Among counties with at least 15,000 owners who pay for insurance, here's where the share was highest.1

County Share paying $4,000 or more Margin of error
Monroe County, FL 49.7% ±3.0 pts
Miami-Dade County, FL 42.3% ±0.6 pts
Orleans Parish, LA 41.9% ±1.0 pts
Broward County, FL 40.9% ±0.5 pts
Palm Beach County, FL 37.6% ±0.7 pts
Jefferson Parish, LA 34.5% ±1.1 pts
Martin County, FL 34.2% ±1.6 pts
Nevada County, CA 28.4% ±1.8 pts
Collier County, FL 27.8% ±0.9 pts
Walton County, FL 27.8% ±2.8 pts

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, ACS 2020–2024 5-year, table B25141. Owners who report paying $100 or more a year. Margins of error at 90% confidence.

In the Florida Keys, about half of paying owners reported $4,000 or more, even before 2025. In Miami-Dade, New Orleans and Broward, it was about 2 in 5.

The top of the county list is mostly coast. A few places stand out anyway:

  • Nevada County, California, in the Sierra foothills, is wildfire country, not hurricane country.
  • Douglas County, Colorado, south of Denver, is suburban and far from any coast. It was at 20.0% (±1.0 pts), about three times the national 6.4% in the same survey.
  • Collin County, Texas, north of Dallas, is suburban hail country, at 17.9% (±0.7 pts). In 2025, Texas insurers paid out $2,247 in wind and hail claims there for every homeowners policy in force.3

In all, 13 of those 850 counties had at least a quarter of paying owners in the top box in 2020–2024. With state shares up sharply in 2025, that count has likely grown since.

Why "$4,000 or more" is the number we watch

In expensive places, the usual "typical cost" breaks down. When more than half of homeowners are in an open-ended top box, you can't estimate a median from the survey. The share paying $4,000 or more keeps working, so we show it for every area, alongside the typical cost where the survey supports one.

It's also just a clear number. Most people can picture a $4,000 bill.

What it doesn't tell you

A county share doesn't say what you should pay. Two houses on the same street can be thousands of dollars apart, because of the roof, the deductible, the coverage amount and the company.

That's the gap we're trying to fill. Share what you pay, and you'll see exactly where you stand among homes near you. Upload your policy declarations page (the summary page of your policy), and your rate counts as verified, which makes the numbers better for your neighbors too.

Sources

  1. U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2025 1-year estimates, table B25141, Homeowners Insurance Costs by Mortgage Status. Owner-reported yearly cost of fire, hazard and flood insurance. Shares and medians count owners who report paying $100 or more a year. Nation: 87,511,734 owner households, 74,695,820 of them reporting $100 or more; 8,706,227 (11.7%) of those at $4,000 or more; median about $1,706 (estimated from the survey's ranges). With a mortgage 12.2%, without 10.8%. County figures, Colorado's 2020–2024 share and the national 2020–2024 share (6.4%) are from the ACS 2020–2024 5-year estimates; the county table covers the 850 counties with at least 15,000 owners reporting $100 or more. Counted against all owners, including those reporting under $100, the 2025 national share is 9.9% and the median about $1,451. See our methodology. ↩

  2. U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2023 1-year estimates, table B25141: 5,378,186 owner households at $4,000 or more. Census reported "over 5.3 million" in its June 2025 story on property insurance costs: https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2025/06/property-insurance.html ↩

  3. Texas Department of Insurance, Homeowners losses by county, 2025: paid wind and hail losses per homeowners policy in force, Collin County. https://tdi.texas.gov/consumer/homeowners-losses-by-county.html ↩

Data as of Census ACS 2025 1-year (states, nation) and 2020–2024 5-year (counties); TDI 2025. Every number in this story comes from a fixed run of our data pipeline (acs_home 2026-11-14T22:26:00Z; tx_tdi 2026-11-14T17:49:03Z), so it won't change under you. No savings promises, no company rankings.

Your home policy

What do you pay for home insurance?

Share your yearly premium and see exactly where you stand among homes near you. Three questions, about 20 seconds, no account needed.

Check your home policy

Free. We never sell your data.